Syrah Tasting Stories
Monday, January 26th, 2009This month our tasting group did a blind tasting of four wines: all labeled syrah. There are more photos of the event on our Facebook page.

We carefully examined and compared our tasting notes, noting the varying tastes of those present. There was, however, a clear winner, and we had to dig into the library to supply the demand for it once we’d tasted it.

The winner was the Long Shadows Sequel Syrah 2004. Smoke and bacon fat, rubbery berry goodness. Blueberry, chocolate and anise, People kept going back to bag #3 for another taste. Not only was it the winner by an overwhelming majority, it also happened to be the oldest of the four wines tasted.

From L to R: Snoqualmie 2006 Columbia Valley Syrah; 2005 Black Tie Syrah, Napa Valley; Helix 2005 Columbia Valley Syrah; Sequel Syrah 2004.
Further tasting notes on the Sequel:
Wine Spectator 92 points. Smooth and velvety, this is a graceful, beautifully balanced Syrah that shows off its blueberry and plum fruit against shades of white pepper and cedar. The finish keeps welling up with haunting flavors. Drink now through 2014. 1,359 cases made. -HS
Sequel Syrah from Longshadows Vintners’ 2003 vintage received 92 points from Wine Spectator too. This second 2004 release is darkly-hued with cherry and cassis aromas to match. This is a focused Syrah loaded with black fruit, spice and a hint of vanilla across a supple frame. Give it time in the glass to fully reveal the wine’s layers of fruit and concentration.
Made by John Duval, the very famous winemaker who for fifteen years made Australia’s most celebrated wine, Penfold’s Grange.
Yakima Valley’s Boushey Vineyard (35%) gives the wine its elegance and balance; Alder Ridge (24%) and Wallula Vineyard (7%) in the Horse Heaven Hills combines with Red Mountain vineyards (32%) to add black fruit and richness. A small amount of Cabernet Sauvignon from Sagemoor’s Dionysus Vineyard on a southwest facing slope in Pasco adds complexity and more layers.
The Black Tie was said to be the most fruit forward, though several people couldn’t get past the nose. The Snoqualmie was the academics’ choice, a cheap red wine for frequent consumption–helps us get through all those papers while not breaking our budget. Not highly recommended for the connoisseurs. And the Helix easily ranked Second Place in the blind tasting.
It’s a bit unfair, perhaps, to taste a $5 bottle of mass produced California syrah next to a $65 bottle of Long Shadows proportions. But it was educational to say the least. What a lovely evening we had! Come by and see the collection of tasting notes. It’s endlessly fascinating.
Remember that every third Thursday we have a tasting group that meets from 7 - 9 p.m. at our shipping center. Come join us next. Wine category to be announced, so stay tuned.